Thursday, May 10, 2018

The Journey of Dignified Mensuration in Nepal: Missing the links


Introduction:
Menstruation is defined by the English Oxford Dictionary is a process in a woman of discharging the blood and other materials from the lining of the uterus at intervals of about one lunar month from puberty until menopause, except during pregnancy. It is natural, developmental process and symbol of reproduction.  


Menstrual Health Management the absorption of menstrual blood on to clean material which can be changed in privacy and also incorporate the availability of soap and clean water, to wash re -usable sanitary materials and the body, as well as suitable place of disposal for used materials (WHO-UNICEF, 2012).  The concept of MHM is emerged recently in development though not clear and not enough to address the comprehensive needs, priorities and rights of menstrual girls and women globally (Inga T. Winkler, 2015). Because the global construction of menstruation is vary though associated with stigma, restrictions, polluted, impure, dirty, contagious, secrecy, shame, silence, inferior, humiliation, powerless etc. since civilization to date (Patkar A., 2013; Lee J. 2003; Paudel R., 2015). More importantly, the menstruation is beyond the infrastructure (Yesmin, 2008).
The May 28 is identified the International Menstrual Hygiene Day (MH day) and celebrated globally since 2014 (28 May, 2014) that created a common space to all stakeholders who works around menstruation hygiene. The month of May symbolically represent the average five days of bleeding during menstruation and 28 represents the average days of menstrual cycle of a normal girl and women. Every year, it was celebrated with slogans/themes: 'wherever she is in privacy, safety and with dignity' (2014), 'raise awareness about women who don't have access to safe water, hygiene and sanitation' (2015), 'menstruation matters to everyone, everywhere' everyday can be a good day' (2016),'education about menstruation changes everything' (2017).

In Nepal, few organizations such as Action Works Nepal, Water Aid Nepal were celebrated 2014 as 28 May by organizing various awareness raising programs at their respective locations. The two more years also remained as disassociation among actors or interested organizations marked 28 May, International Menstruation Hygiene day with thinner connection with concerned line agencies. In February 2017, Ministry of Water Supply and Sanitation organized a national consultation workshop along with Ministry of Women and Children Development, Ministry of Education and Ministry of Health and other local and external development partners and declared as Nagarkot Declaration 2017 (MoWSS, 2017). It urged few things: formulation of national policy on menstruation, build capacity of actors as well as raise massive awareness around menstruation.

Followed by the consultation workshop, the policy drafting committee formed under the leadership of joint secretary. The committee initiate the concept of dignified menstruation in order to address all kinds of needs, interest and priorities of girls and women during period and beyond. It is a simply beyond the infrastructure and hygiene. It is holistic approach where menstruation accepted natural process and considered human right concern thus assures the needs and priorities of girls and women during period such as health, education, shelter, nutrition, law, safety, security, empowerment, environment, water supply and sanitation (Sanitation, 2017).

MHM-PA Alliance
The members of the policy drafting committee initiated the MHM-PA (Menstrual Hygiene Management-Partner Alliance). As a result, in April, 2017, more than 30 organizations came together and formed MHM-PA in order to work broadly around menstruation at local, national and global level as partnering organization of government. The membership of this group is free and any interested organizations or individuals can join and contribute accordingly where CODEF played as secretariat. In general, the most of organizations associated with big organizations due to having international organizations as well as financial transactions such as WaterAid Nepal, KIRDAC, CODEF/WSSCC, HELVITAS Nepal etc. More importantly, they are working direct on WASH (water, sanitation and hygiene) and they are working around menstruation for few years already. The X-Pose Nepal is small but working in advocacy as well as awareness raising around menstruation for couple of years back where as Radha Paudel Foundation (RPF) is massively involved in research, policy advocacy, campaigns and trainings at local, national and global level without any specific funding resource.

Methodology:
This is qualitative study, used primary and secondary data through observation and reviewed of reports of member organizations of MHM-PA Alliance. Total 14 organizations were submitted to secretariat office by 12 MHM-PA members (CODEF/WSSCC, 2017)s as MHM-PA alliance agreed to mark international menstrual hygiene day for a week, effective from 22-31 May, 2017.  They were; i) CODEF(Community Development Forum), ii) Federation of Water Users, iii) IWRMP, iv) Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Fund Development Board (Fund Board), v) Guthi, vi) HELVITAS Nepal,  vii) Nepal Red Cross Society, viii) Putali Nepal, ix) Radha Paudel Foundation (RPF), x) Visible Impact, xi) Water Aid Nepal and xii) X-Pose Nepal. In terms of locations, activities were reached out in all levels; local, national and global level. The activities mainly focused on 14 different districts of the country; Lalitpur, Kathmandu, Bhaktapur, Dang, Rolpa, Banke, Surkhet, Jajarkot, Dailekh Rukum,Dolpa, Kalikot, Jumla and Achham. The components of dignified menstruation were covered or not, what are the major gaps in practice are analysed and discussed such as health, education, shelter, nutrition, law, safety, security, empowerment, environment, water supply and sanitation.

Analysis and Discussions: 
i) CODEF(Community Development Forum):
The media interaction program with live was observed at the premises of CIN (Community Information Network) in collaboration with          CODEF (Community Development Forum) on 22 May, 2017 where 40 journalists from     TV, radio and newspapers attended.  There were      key speakers; Tika Dahal (people with disability perspectives), Saru Joshi (breaking the silence), Anupa Regmi (physiology of                    menstruation), Gunraj Shrestha (relevancy of 28 May celebration), Radha Paudel (from the human right perspectives). Except Radha   Paudel, the discussion largely focused on hygiene, unintentionally concentrated around sanitary pads and breaking the silence.
            Despite having first program of this year, the different dimensions of dignified menstruation such as health, education, shelter, nutrition,   law, safety, security, empowerment, environment, water supply and sanitation were heavily ignored except water supply and sanitation.

ii) FEDWASUN
An interaction program was participated and observed by the writer of this report. There were three lawmakers from the Constituent Assembly though the discussion was so superficial in perspective of dignified menstruation. It was more focused on water supply in toilets and hygiene but not discussed health, shelter, nutrition, law, safety, security, empowerment, environment.

iii) IWRMP
IWRMP supported to radio program where interviewed were taken with representatives from different organization, teachers, health officers where they shared their views and work experience of their respective organization through Jagarn Special Programme in Surkhet. The dignity of the girls and women during menstruation is missing here. It developed an approach of Hygiene Literacy Class in the community too. Total sanitation and hygiene promotion flip chart has developed which has 12 chapter including Menstruation Hygiene (Chapter 7). Thus, the dignity perspective of the menstruation largely ignored. 

iv) Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Fund Development Board (Fund Board)
            Two panel discussions conducted by Fund Board in Kathmandu. The first was concentrated on the slogan of the year 2017 entitled          'education on menstruation change everything' where the joint secretary and spokesperson from the ministry of education from government             (Hari Lamsal), representative from LGBTQI (Lesbian, Gay, Bi-sexual, Transsexual, Queer and Intrasexual) Durga Thapa and national             association of people with disability (Rama Dhakal) and social activists (Dr Aruna Uprety and Radha Paudel) were there. The writers of     this report participated and observed the program. The half of the discussion lively discussed on dignified menstruation. 
           
            The second panel discussion entitled 'Can multi-sectoral approach be a game changer to create safer and healthier experience for all girls         and women' which composed of five panellists from Institute of Medicine, Nardevi Ayurvedic Hospital, Activist for people living with            disability, YUWA and Visible Impact. They were given different perspectives on menstruation as breaking silence and focused on hygiene        but heavily ignored the dignity of the girls and women during period.

v) Guthi,
In collaboration with WaterAid Nepal, ENPHO. ACF International (Action Against Hunger- Nepal) and Jasmine Group (Safety Sanitary Napkins), Guthi organized public male sensitization program on menstruation in Langankhel bus park, Lalitpur.
The public male personalities invited; Mr. Madan Krishna Shrestha, Ravi Dongol along with Deputy Director of Department of Water Supply and Sewerage; Senior Public Health Administrator, Ministry of Health and other stakeholders were male members of the group who accepted on wearing a pad and even shared their experience and their feelings without any hesitation. Approximately 100 public participation was observed in the event. The writers observed that event primarily breaking the silence and focused on infrastructure.

vi) HELVITAS Nepal
Despite involvement at national level activities, the partner organizations conducted different events; rally, quizzes, essays and elocution, competitions programme on menstrual hygiene and Chhaupadi related theme for promoting awareness and to break the silence on menstruation in its working districts, Dailekh, Achham,Kalikot , Jajarkot and Surkhet. with students, teachers, parents, representative from health post, and representative of local political parties. The celebration with different Programme in different schools supported to break the silence on menstruation and was successful in creating awareness on several misconceptions and practices associated with menstruation.

vii) Nepal Red Cross Society (NRCS)
  NRCS organized few activities such as interaction program on menstrual hygiene, to mark May 28, International Menstrual Hygiene Day in various villages of Solukhumbu, Mahottari, Rautahat, Bara, Kathmandu, Parbat, Kalikot, Jajarkot, Achham, Bhajyang of its working areas. All activities focused on hygiene during menstruation.

 viii) Putali Nepal
Putali Nepal organized training on Ruby Cup in cooperation with Hands in Outreach (HIO) to 21 women who are part of their literacy
program. Ruby Cup is an alternative and eco-friendly menstrual cup that can be used as a safe method to deal with periods. The information about the Ruby Cup contained details about the products material, it’s usage (insertion, removal, emptying, cleaning and storing it), frequently asked questions, like “Do I lose my virginity using the Ruby Cup?” or “Will the cup overflow?”. Also offered more generals trainings on MHM addressing these and related issues during which we use the Menstrupedia Comic book as well. Likewise, Putali Nepal also organized Menstrupedia training in school. The first session was given to 16 girls and in the second
training 31 boys participated. All in all, all activities are focused on sanitary products specially on Ruby Cup and hygiene.

ix) Radha Paudel Foundation (RPF)
RPF organized various programs at local, national and global level by giving radio interview, article writings, panellist and participated in many programs. All in all, programs focused on dignity and human right of girls and women during menstruation. RPF also emphasis that theChhaupadi is a form of menstrual restrictions which is visible in west Nepal but practicing across country regardless of caste, education, religion, region etc.  

 x) Visible Impact
It has organized educational interaction program focusing on menstruation, health facilities in schools and role of men. It has touched the few parts of dignified menstruation but not in holistic manner.

 xi) UN Habitat
UN Habitat organized programs in schools and village councils in five different districts of Nepal namely Arghakhanchi, Bajura, saptari, Siraha, Jhapa. According to secondary information, the video show, interaction, discussion were programs for breaking silence and improving hygiene and sanitation during menstruation. The dignity or human right component was not the core of the discussion.

xii) Water Aid Nepal
As an International non-governmental organization, has part of various activities through partner organization in Kathmandu and outside. However, it largely focused on menstrual hygiene, water supply sanitation but not health, shelter, nutrition, law, safety, security, empowerment, environment.

 xii) X-Pose Nepal
The cycle rally was organized by X-Pose Nepal. It was first cycle rally on menstruation where more than 200 cyclists participated from various walks of the life. It started from Basantapur Darbar Square and ended at Patan Darbar Square followed by small corner assembly. It was focused on awareness raising on menstruation, specially breaking the silence around boys and men in Kathmandu through observation and media coverage. Only two speakers out of six linked the menstruation with human right. It didn't speak on other aspects of the dignified menstruation.

Conclusion and Recommendations
  Conclusion: The talk around menstruation is started in Nepal in 2017. The government, NGOs and individuals are initiated the culture to work collectively to fight against the taboos of menstruation. Its just beginning and long way to go to get tangible impacts in the life of girls and women as well as in society. The discourse just started from the point of hygiene and sanitation and the course has to go further wide and depth to assure the dignity of the girls and women during period.

  Recommendation:
1.      This is the high time to abolish restrictions around menstruation and empower girls and women since childhood.  Therefore, government needs to call for urgent action to all stakeholders who are working about health, education, empowerment, human right and SDGs in order to address the different dimensions of the menstrual rights.
2.      The government also need to develop guidelines to monitor the activities of NGOs at central as well as provincial level.
3.      The research and policy attention is lack around dignified menstruation therefore it has to increase significantly by government.
4.      NGOs are also hold accountability to redress the violations of human right and disempowerment. Regardless of their mandate of project, the message of dignified menstruation has to disseminate across their project as cross cutting concern.

References

28 May, m. H. (2014). Retrieved from 28 May, Menstrual Hygiene Day: http://menstrualhygieneday.org
CODEF/WSSCC. (2017). MHM-PA Summary Report, MH day 2017. Kathmandu: Unpublished.
Inga T. Winkler, V. R. (2015). Taking the Bloody Linen out of the Closet:Menstrual Hygiene as a Priority for Achieving Gender Equality.
MoWSS. (2017, February). www.mowss.org.np. Retrieved from Ministry of Water Supply and Sanitation: www.mowss.org.np
Sanitation, M. o. (2017). Zero Draft Policy on Dignified Menstruation 2074. Kathmandu: Ministry of Water Supply and Sanitation.
WHO-UNICEF. (2012). Consultation on Drfat long list of goal, target and indicator options for future globalmonitoringof water, sanitation and hygiene. WHO-UNICEF.
Yesmin, O. A. (2008). Menstrual Hygiene; Breaking the Silence in Beyond Construction.



 Tuka Chhetri Sandwell, her son James Sandwell were here in Nepal and visited Bhaktapur, Sipaghaat, Parasi (Tihar celebration), Gorkha Kalik...